[identity profile] mithrigil.livejournal.com posting in [community profile] kinkfest

 

Title: Should
Fandom: Final Fantasy XII

Characters: Ashe and Basch

Author/Artist: mithrigil
Rating: R
Warnings: Bondage, and neither party knows the rules.
Word count: 1400
Summary: Ashe would know the extent of Basch’s investment in…this.

 

Should

Mithrigil Galtirglin

 

“I want you to tie me up.”

 

What would have been a protestation sits hoarse and dry at the rim of Basch’s throat.

 

The clarification comes quick, “As a measure of your investment in this. We have been having sex for some time now,” and she says it so calmly, only the faintest hint of a disbelieving stutter before that phrase, ‘having sex’, as if there is nothing else to call it, and Basch is certain that there is something else to call it, “and it is always left to me to—to initiate it. And direct it. And I would know that you are not merely allowing me to use you.”

 

“Of course not,” he manages to say without hitching, by breathing deep and twice and holding her eyes. Surely she is not fully resolved in this. Surely not, if she savors her blinks, if her chest heaves so slightly.

 

“And no doubt the image has crossed your mind,” she prompts.

 

“Never,” he says truly.

 

She smiles a bit. “It is now.”

 

It is.

 

“Basch.”

 

He is honest with her, slow with his speech. “It is not an enticing thing to me, to think of you bound.” To think of anyone bound, he does not say. His hands are curled into fists on his thighs, beneath the table, digging into him the way his heels dig into the floor. “But I will do as my Lady commands.”

 

She seethes. “That is not what this should be about.”

 

As she leans her palms into the table and gets to her feet—slow as his words—Basch stares. He holds her eyes, consoles himself with the flickers of uncertainty in them, does not flinch as she comes around to his side of the table, and then to his side. Her palm and fingers are warm on his neck, grit with dead skin that she has ceased to care for in these months afield. She leans down to him, but does not loom over, and that seems a concession.

 

“You should desire this,” she says, and Basch know she does not mean bondage, does not mean games. She means he should desire “What we have,” she goes on, “what I am entrusting you with. Or else we should not have begun this at all.”

 

He agrees. She kneads the juncture of his neck. He still agrees.

 

“And I want that,” she says, and there has not been a stutter in the resolve of her eyes since she began with her logic. “I want you to…to do what you want with me.”

 

What she does not say—Basch hears it—is that she knows not how else to go about it. That if she has any part in this at all, he is not acting on his own desires.

 

“I cannot make you want this,” she admits, eyes closed, head bowed over his, and he nearly reaches up to touch her cheeks. “I should not be making you want this.”

 

“You are not,” he tells her plain.

 

“Then you should not have to prove to me that you do.”

 

“No,” he agrees, “I should not.”

 

The image is still in his mind, where she thrust it unbidden—of her in his restraints, that cage, blood spattered in widening streaks on her shoulders, her cheeks. But that is not what she intends, he tells himself, and leans up into her touch. When did he close his eyes? The hand on his skin is reassuring in its warmth, its subtle urgency.

 

He admits, “I do not know what you want.”

 

“Don’t take it into account.” She rakes a palm up to his day’s-beard, brushes her fingers against his hair. “It is not…it amounts to wanting to know. What you would have of me.”

 

“And you think you will learn this by—”

 

“By not showing you what I want. By…by trusting you with that.”

 

His lips are closed, his eyes are open. Hers are the same.

 

“Tonight,” he tells her. “Second watch.”

 

“Yes.”

 

-

 

Her tent, he assumes. In the past, she has always come to him. If this is to be different, it is to be different, and so he raps his toe on the nearest post, twice, once soft, once hard. The second knock is loud enough to make him shiver—however far they are from the nomads’ encampment, and from the others, the tone still rings through the clear air. And she draws him in quickly, and it is not so dark that he can ignore the raised brows, the resigned surprise on her face.

 

The tentflap closes—it is dark now, and she is against him, and the cloth walls close around and over him. It takes moments for him to remember that he must kiss her first. He doesn’t. “Have you—”

 

“Beside the bedroll,” she answers, and her knees are sharp on his hips. “You…you are going to do this?”

 

She wants only to hear ‘yes’. He keeps the reasons to himself.

 

            He finds no rope beside them—her belts and baldric wound into coils, instead. The leather of it is slick in his hands, as his lips are with the questions of how she means for this to happen, why she means for this to happen, but he bites back those words, pinning them to the bedroll under his knees. She does not so much as offer up her hands to him—he has to find them, take them, has to feel her skin trembling and wonder if the shivering is actually his own.

 

            Dare he ask if she is certain?

 

            Instead, he kisses her. This he can do, and not just to buy him time to decide. He loves the way she kisses, and that has not changed, still this powerful, cowing ardor. Even as they lay, with her beneath him, the kiss is hers, and he is at the mercy of it.

 

            His fists tighten around the belts he has gathered. Her meaning is clear.

 

            As he raises her arms over her head, supports himself above her, he cannot help but think there is something missing, something he should say. The skin of her forearms is smooth, goosefleshed as he nooses the braid of her baldric around them. He is still not desirous of this, and doubtless she can feel that from how they are sprawled, and her hips pulse under his, testing, goading. She does dictate this, even when she is holding herself back, her meaning is clear, and he wonders where her blade is, if he’s using the strap of the sheath to bind her to a tentpost.

 

            A faint gasp beads against his collar. He stops, grits his teeth, and rises from her. He skulks on fours to the post—cannot ask if she is comfortable, cannot ask if this is good—and loops the baldric through a belt, and knots it there.

 

            He must ask, he must, “Is this enough?”

 

            She curls over, testing the restraint, and smirks. “I know not,” she whispers. “Is it?”

 

            He will not say that he wants what is best for her.

 

            Returning to her side, drawing a hand along the knots to make sure they are tight enough not to rake—he knows restraints, knows what will hurt, and wishes none of it upon her—he recoils from the shudder of her skin, from the terse, quiet laughter on her lips. He has forgotten to remove her clothing. He is incredulous.

 

            Yet one of his hands is gathering the fabric at her side. The heel of his palm slides up her skin as he bares it. She has taken off her armor and cincher, at least, for sleep, but the rest of her is girt and decent. She had made no move to protest this. She has given him no instructions.

 

            Something clicks into place.

 

            He knows how much she wants this, by how her lips halt before the commands can form, by the stutter of her elbows off the ground, by her eyes as they fight to stay open. His hands are beneath her shirt now, he still does not believe he neglected to remove it, and cold crawls through every hair on his skin.

 

            “You,” she breathes up at him, and there is anger in it, resignation, disbelief, “you…do not.”

 

            “No,” he whispers, and even he can barely hear it. “Not like this. Not like this.”

 

 

---



.

Date: 2007-07-30 03:58 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] laylah.livejournal.com
oh, Mith. I love how well you portray his struggle, here -- how much he wants to make her happy and how much he doesn't want to do what she demands; how deeply he's scarred from Nalbina and how much she doesn't have the ability to negotiate what she actually wants from him without asking for things he can't, despite his best efforts, make himself give.

Date: 2007-07-30 04:06 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] laylah.livejournal.com
I was glad to see you take it -- I knew I could trust you to really get into how difficult the power issues would be.

Date: 2007-07-30 04:10 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] laylah.livejournal.com
I badly wanted -- and was quite happy to get -- her in the restraints, at her insistence. She can't seem to give up control even when she makes it an order. Poor both of them. ^^;

Date: 2007-07-30 04:20 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] lynndyre.livejournal.com
Eeek. Poor, poor Basch. I love how clear it is that Ashe is demanding he want to give her what *she* wants - that awful sort of 'Dom me, exactly the way I want'.

And she has no *empathy*. You write the badsex so well.

Date: 2007-07-30 04:44 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] lynndyre.livejournal.com
For me, this felt like it went beyond the sub being technically in control and all the way into topping from the bottom.

But the worst is that Basch ... can't say no, for all that he hates it. Can't ever say no. The only way not to do it... is to fail.

And you're very welcome.

Date: 2007-07-30 04:32 am (UTC)
threewalls: threewalls (Default)
From: [personal profile] threewalls
Ow.

And, oh, thank goodness she finally gets it. I hope. Because as fascinating as it is to watch Basch suffer, I'd prefer it inflicted with conscious intent rather than by an accident that intended pleasure.

Even with their affection for each other, I can't see them without the shadow of Ashe abusing power over him she refuses to be responsible for (or, at the least, seeks to circumvent).

Date: 2007-07-30 05:09 am (UTC)
threewalls: threewalls (Default)
From: [personal profile] threewalls
Hmm. I read it as Ashe wanting to specifically to be bound and taken, rather than thinking of her being the one bound as a compromise for his interests. After all, if the point of the scene is for Basch to take her as he will, what purpose would binding *him* serve?

Out of curiosity, are we supposed to read into this that she's known someone else who was more amenable to such games, either in theory or practice? She seems very surprised that Basch hasn't fantasised about her in bondage-- though that could of course only be Ashe projecting her own fantasies, and that's just led me to the uncomfortable thought that Ashe came up with something like this in the hopes of later reciprocal Basch bondage.

And this occurs 706-7 OV, during the game? That is early.

Date: 2007-07-30 04:41 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] puella-nerdii.livejournal.com
Shivers.

I think this line is what got me most:
She curls over, testing the restraint, and smirks. “I know not,” she whispers. “Is it?”

Because it's Ashe trying to give Basch what she thinks he wants and Basch wanting to give her what she thinks she wants and both of them not knowing and yeah. I can feel how deeply it hurts Basch to do this, even though it's what Ashe says she wants, and I love how she's still not really ceding her power to him even when she instructs him to bind her.

Gorgeous, though. Really gorgeous.

Date: 2007-07-30 04:47 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] puella-nerdii.livejournal.com
*nods* What they have definitely isn't romance -- especially when you write it. It is still, however, quite hot.

Date: 2007-07-30 04:47 am (UTC)
ext_13601: (broken song birthright)
From: [identity profile] who-shot-kr.livejournal.com
God, you have a way with tension. It's a frigging trainwreck speeding out of control and you know it within the first couple exchanges between them alone, but still, you cannot look away, nor do you want to look away.

It hurts, Mith. But you hit in such a way that it's a good hurt, and asadn. I keep reading because of that.

(Vossler's waiting in the war room with a tub of ice cream and the latest field reports should Basch, you know, need it. XDD)

Date: 2007-07-30 04:19 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] lindenleaves.livejournal.com
He will not say that he wants what is best for her is, I believe, my favorite line. It's Ashe and Basch at their best and worst here, both as individuals and as a couple. And the contrast of Ashe's desire to be bound vs. Basch's desire for freedom for himself and everyone he cares for works on so, SO many levels.

Was she doing it primarily for him, or for herself?

Date: 2007-07-30 06:42 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] jpegasus.livejournal.com
*prrr*
fabulous. poor basch, trying so hard.And poor ashe, learning that you cant really inflict your kinks on other people, if you want them to stay actively involved.

Date: 2007-07-30 08:20 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] wodhaund.livejournal.com
Perfect. Yes.

Date: 2007-07-31 02:05 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] mad-rex.livejournal.com
The most painful piece I've read from you yet, Reconstruction included.

It did not occur to me, for some reason, just how queer this prompt was until halfway through the fic, when you slammed the brakes on what had until then been an almost humorous experience. I wondered how far you would take it, how you could possibly make this work. Instead, you didn't make it work--in the most gutwrenching, heartrending way possible. It was a direction I never expected going in, and once again I am simply stunned by your writing.

The idea that this piece is a "study" is applicable in more ways than one. Your dedication to the characters is astounding; neither Ashe nor Basch will yield, will bend, will break, will anything for this. Ashe has to have things her way, whether it's the relationship or the encounter; Basch agrees to an admirable extent, but not enough to face his demons (or at least not this one) during a time of release. You provide so much insight into the minds of these two, into the perils of their relationship.

This is also, to a surprising degree, a study of the sadomasochistic mind. Ashe doesn't really want control, here--she wants to be without it, for once, even if she has to use control to get it (as she does with all things). I don't pretend to be anything of an expert on this kink, but the idea of dominators wanting to be dominated is one I've seen echoed elsewhere. It's not one I've personally applied to Ashe in the past, but it fits remarkably well here; her attempt to disguise her "strange" desires made it particularly convincing.

To be honest, I'm a touch relieved right along with you at [livejournal.com profile] laylah's words. I enjoyed this story immensely for the character work, but I wondered how well it would be received by the requester; it's so different, after all, from what the average person would have wanted from this prompt. I'm quite glad to see it was indeed appreciated, especially if it encourages you to take similar risks in the future. I can get kinkfic anywhere, after all...but fics as interesting as this one are both much more difficult to come by and much more fulfilling.

(These damn things just get longer and longer, don't they. =/ I'm trying to control myself, I swear....)

Date: 2007-07-31 03:02 am (UTC)
lassarina: (Basch: Even Caged Birds Need Wings)
From: [personal profile] lassarina
I loved this when first I saw it, and I love it even more now. The tension between them is perfect, and her utter confounded reaction when she realizes he truly doesn't want this, and the shadow of Nalbina hanging over his head. it's all so well-woven, and just. Yes.

Date: 2007-07-31 02:31 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] rampant-geekery.livejournal.com
Well...everyone has already said what I wanted to say, so I'll just go with the ol' tried and true I Liked It. :B

Date: 2007-07-31 08:56 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] first-seventhe.livejournal.com
Absolutely brilliant, really. I love that Ashe can't - won't - relinquish control - but that she wants to so badly that she'd ask this of Basch, not really realizing - now I am making no sense at all. This:

“But I will do as my Lady commands.”

She seethes. “That is not what this should be about.”


- KILLS me.

And, oh, Basch. He breaks my little heart.

Profile

kinkfest

August 2017

S M T W T F S
  12345
67 89101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Apr. 11th, 2026 09:06 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios